Cormac RepmanBlogHome
Cormac Repman

Benchmark Each Rep Against the Seat They Dial

7 November 2026

I have watched managers pull a rep into a one-on-one because their numbers dropped, then discover the rep had been moved onto a finance list the week before. The rep was fine. The scoreboard was lying.

If you run a team, or you are the team, this is worth fixing today. Not all dials are the same dial.

The floor average hides the seat

Over the last 90 days, across 2.0M dials, finance titles (CFO, Controller, VP Finance) booked one meeting per 1,404 dials. CEOs and founders booked one per 877. Other C-suite, one per 1,182. Managers, one per 764.

Same scripts, same dialer, same coffee. Nearly double the dials between the easiest seat and the hardest one.

Per conversation it is tighter, but the order holds. Finance books 2.2% of conversations. CEOs 2.5%, other C-suite 2.7%, VPs 3.2%, managers 3.3%. The higher the title, the lower the book rate.

So if you rank reps by meetings booked per dial across one blended number, you are mostly ranking their lists. Finance is the hardest seat on the phone, and whoever gets it looks worse.

The conversations are different, too

This is the part that matters for coaching. Reps on finance lists are not hearing the same objections as reps on manager lists.

Finance conversations end as "follow up required" 47.5% of the time, the highest of any group. Managers sit at 36%. And "no need" shows up in only 5.5% of finance conversations, the lowest of any group. CEOs say it 9.3% of the time, managers 11.6%.

CFOs rarely tell you there is no problem. They tell you to call back. They defer instead of refusing.

Now picture the coaching mistake. A rep on a finance list has a pile of "call me back" outcomes and few hard rejections. It feels like progress. The manager sees a low rejection rate and says nothing. Meanwhile almost half the conversations are going into a drawer.

A rep on a manager list gets more flat "no need" and "not interested." That rep needs help with rejection. The finance rep needs help turning a deferral into a dated next step. Those are different skills, and one blended scorecard will not tell you which one is missing.

Time is different by seat

Average finance conversation: 83 seconds. CEOs: 79. Other C-suite: 88. Managers: 105.

Managers give you roughly 20 more seconds. That does not sound like much until you remember a finance conversation has to earn a next step in under a minute and a half. A rep who is fine at 105 seconds can be in trouble at 83, because the same opener now eats a bigger share of the call.

Also, 29% of CEO conversations are rejected at the intro or the pitch. Finance is 23%, other C-suite 27%, managers 24%. Roughly a quarter to a third of senior conversations end before you ask anything. If your rep on a CEO list has a high rate of dead intros, that is the seat talking, not necessarily a weak opener. Test the opener before you rewrite the rep.

Pick-up rates punish the senior seat

One more distortion. Dials to CEOs turned into conversations 4.6% of the time. Dials to contacts with no title on file: 7.3%. Senior people pick up less.

A rep dialing senior lists burns more dials per live human. They also get fewer reps at the actual skill, because the number of conversations they have per hour is lower. Practice volume is part of performance. Lower conversation volume means slower improvement, and that will show up in your numbers if you ignore it.

Build a seat baseline in an afternoon

You do not need a data team. You need a spreadsheet and your last 90 days.

  1. Tag every dial by seat: finance, CEO or founder, other C-suite, VP, manager, no title.
  2. For each seat, calculate dials per booked meeting and bookings per conversation. That is your baseline.
  3. For each rep, compute their expected result given the mix of seats they dialed. Compare actual to expected, not actual to the floor.
  4. Split outcomes by seat too. Track "follow up required" separately from hard no, because the same rate means different things in different seats.
  5. Pull the finance-heavy reps out for a separate review on one question: how many of their deferrals ended with a specific date?

Step three is the one that stops you from punishing the wrong person. A rep who is slightly under baseline on the hardest seat may be your best caller. A rep who is slightly over baseline on managers may be coasting.

What this does to the people

There is a psychological cost to the uncorrected scoreboard. Reps who get the hard seats learn that effort is penalized. They start negotiating for easier lists, or they quietly stop dialing the CFOs and dial the people who pick up. Then you wonder why your pipeline is full of the wrong titles.

Fair measurement is not softness. It is how you keep people willing to dial the seat that actually buys.

Rate each rep against the seat they dialed, and you will coach the right problem.

Sales as psychology, weekly

One idea a week on cold calling, objections and getting meetings held. No fluff.