Cormac RepmanBlogHome
Cormac Repman

Coach on Call Length: Listen to the Calls That Die at 40 Seconds

17 November 2026

Most sales coaching starts from the outcome. Booked, good. Not booked, bad. Then someone says "just be more confident" and everyone goes back to the phones feeling vaguely told off.

I've made thousands of cold calls, and outcome tells you almost nothing about what to fix. Length tells you a lot more.

Two numbers that should change how you review calls

The median call that books a meeting runs 312 seconds. A quarter of them are shorter than 196 seconds, and a quarter run past 440. The median conversation that does not book lasts 40 seconds.

A booking is a five-minute call. A rejection is a forty-second call. Those are two different events, not a good version and a bad version of the same one.

Something happens somewhere between second 40 and second 196 that turns a rejection into a booking. That window is where your coaching time belongs. Almost nobody reviews it, because most reviews are driven by a scoreboard that only shows the final result.

Sort by duration, not by disposition

Here's what I'd do today. Open your call recordings and sort by length instead of by outcome. Pull three piles, about five calls each.

Pile one: calls that ended around 40 seconds. These are your typical failures. Listen only to the first half. You are not judging the rep. You are looking for the sentence right before the prospect said goodbye.

Pile two: calls that ran long and still didn't book. These are the interesting ones. The prospect gave you time and you didn't convert it. Usually the rep kept talking when they should have asked, or asked for the meeting in a way that made it sound like a favour.

Pile three: calls that booked. Listen for the turn. Almost every booked call has a moment where the prospect stops reacting and starts participating. They ask a question, or they say something about their own situation without being prompted.

Write down the timestamp of that moment, then write down what the rep said in the ten seconds before it. Do that fifteen times and you'll have a pattern. It won't be a theory, because you'll have fifteen examples of it.

What you're listening for

I can't hand you the answer, because it depends on your product and your reps. But the same things tend to show up.

In the short calls, the rep is mid-pitch when the prospect cuts in. The prospect almost never cuts in during a question. They cut in during a sentence that begins with the company name.

In the booked calls, the turn usually follows a question the prospect had to think about. People don't think when they're being pitched. They think when they're asked something they hadn't planned for.

In the long calls that didn't book, the rep often got a real answer and then changed the subject to their own agenda. Listen for the sound of a good moment being wasted. It's quite distinctive.

Why this matters more with senior buyers

The average finance conversation lasts 83 seconds. CEOs average 79. Other C-suite is 88. Managers get 105.

That's the whole budget. You have under a minute and a half, on average, to earn the next step. If your rep's typical call to a senior person dies at 40 seconds, they've used about half the time that call normally lasts and have no idea why.

The reason to review by length is that it shows you where the time went. A rep who loses finance leaders at 25 seconds has an opener problem. A rep who loses them at 70 seconds has a question problem. The scoreboard calls both of those "not interested", and the fix for each is different.

How to run the session

Keep it to thirty minutes with one rep. Don't play them the worst call you could find, because that turns it into a trial.

Play them one short call and one booked call from their own recordings. Ask two questions: "Where did the prospect stop listening?" and "Where did they start?" Reps are good at answering these about their own calls once they hear them back. They're terrible at answering them from memory, because memory edits out the awkward bits.

Then agree on one change. Not five. One. Maybe it's cutting the second sentence of the opener. Maybe it's asking something before describing anything. Maybe it's shutting up for two seconds after a prospect's first real answer.

Next week, pull the same rep's calls and check whether the short pile got smaller or the turn came earlier. If neither moved, the change was wrong, and you try another. That's still faster than a month of motivational talks.

The trap to avoid

Don't turn call length into a target. A rep told to keep calls longer will start rambling, and a rambling call is just a slower rejection. Length is a diagnostic. It shows you where to look, and the thing to fix is what happens inside the call.

Also, ignore the average of your own calls. Averages hide the two groups. Look at the short ones and the long ones separately, because the useful differences sit in the gap between them.

Sort your recordings by duration today, and listen for the moment the prospect starts talking.

Sales as psychology, weekly

One idea a week on cold calling, objections and getting meetings held. No fluff.