Cormac RepmanBlogHome
Cormac Repman

Give Your Hardest Seat the Best Hour of the Day

12 November 2026

Most dial lists get worked in whatever order the CRM spits them out. Alphabetical, by upload date, by whoever imported the file. Then the team wonders why the afternoon feels like shouting into a well.

Two things in our data, put together, suggest a better way to sort the list. I'll be upfront that the combination is a hypothesis, not a finding. But each half is solid, and the test costs you nothing but a sort order.

Half one: the day gets worse as it goes

Pick-ups roughly halve across the US day. Conversation rate at 12:00 UTC (8am ET) is 8.5%. By 20:00 UTC (4pm ET) it's 4.6%.

Bookings follow. At 8am ET we see 21 meetings booked per 10,000 dials. By 4pm ET that's 12.5. In between it slides: 16.6 around 9 to 10am ET, 15 by 11am to noon.

The same dial, same rep, same script is worth much less at the end of the day. Dials are not equal. Hours are not equal.

Half two: seats are not equal either

Over 90 days and 2.0M dials, finance titles (CFO, Controller, VP Finance) took 1 in 1,404 dials to book a meeting. Managers took 1 in 764. CEOs and founders were 1 in 877, other C-suite 1 in 1,182.

Finance is the hardest seat on the phone. Per conversation it's 2.2% booking for finance against 3.3% for managers. And the conversations are short: an average of 83 seconds for finance. You get under a minute and a half to earn the next step.

So you have a scarce resource, the hours when people actually answer, and a segment that needs every bit of luck it can get. Right now most teams spend that resource at random.

The sort: hardest seats first

Here's what I'd do today. Split your list into two piles.

Pile one: hard seats. Finance titles, and the senior titles who end a third of conversations before you've asked the question. These go into the first dial hours, when somebody is actually at the desk and the phone is still a novelty.

Pile two: easier seats. Managers, directors, anyone where the book rate per conversation is already healthier. These get the afternoon. They convert better per conversation, so they can survive a thinner pick-up rate.

The logic is simple. If pick-ups halve by late afternoon, a hard seat dialed at 4pm is a hard seat with half the chances. A manager dialed at 4pm is an easy seat with half the chances. Give the half-chances to the one who needs fewer.

Why this isn't a cheat

You are not manufacturing meetings. You are moving the same dials to better hours. Total dials stay the same, total contacts stay the same, and the only thing that changes is which contact meets which hour.

Think of it as seating at a restaurant. You don't give the best table to the person who'd have been happy anywhere.

What to watch while you run it

I'd run it for a few weeks, not a few days, because finance volumes are lower and noise is high. Track three things per pile and per hour:

If the hard pile doesn't improve, my hypothesis is wrong, and you've lost nothing. If it does, you've found free performance in a sort order.

The Monday footnote

Monday is the best weekday per dial at 15.3 bookings per 10,000 dials. Tuesday through Friday sit between 13.6 and 14.0. It's not a huge gap, but it's consistent enough to use as a tiebreaker.

If you have a short list of high-value finance contacts and you can only afford a limited number of attempts, spend the first attempt on Monday morning. Not Friday at 4pm, which is where most of those attempts quietly go to die.

What to do with the rep who hates mornings

Every team has one. They'll tell you they warm up slowly and do their best work after lunch.

Maybe. But the data says people pick up less after lunch, and no amount of warmth will fix that. If a rep needs a warm-up, give them the easier pile first for twenty minutes of mornings, then move them onto the hard seats. Better that than burning your best pick-up window on a call you're not ready to make.

I've made thousands of cold calls, and the worst ones were rarely a script problem. They were a me-at-4pm-calling-someone-who-had-already-stopped-answering problem.

Do it before the next dial session

Open your list, add a column for seat type, sort finance and other senior titles to the top, and schedule them into your first dial block tomorrow.

Your best hour of pick-ups should go to the contacts who are hardest to reach, not to whoever happens to be first in the file.

Sales as psychology, weekly

One idea a week on cold calling, objections and getting meetings held. No fluff.