Cormac RepmanBlogHome
Cormac Repman

"Not the Right Person" Is a Lead. Stop Hanging Up on It.

18 November 2026

"I'm not the right person for this."

Most reps hear that and say "no problem, thanks for your time." Then they dial the next number. I did it for years, and it felt polite.

It was also a small act of self-sabotage. This is the one objection where the prospect has handed you the answer and you walk away without taking it.

What the data says about this objection

In our transcripts, 2.5% of conversations contain "not the right person." That is the smallest of the common objections. "Call me back" shows up in 11.3%. "Already have a vendor" shows up in 6.9%. "Not interested" shows up in 5.1%.

So it is rare. That is exactly why nobody practises it. Nobody has a routine for something that happens a couple of times a week.

But think about what it costs to get a conversation at all. Across the floor, it takes 57 conversations to produce one qualified meeting. A conversation is the scarce unit. And a median conversation that does not book lasts 40 seconds. You already spent the effort to get a human on the line, and the human just told you something useful: you have the wrong seat, and they know who has the right one.

Why people say it, and what it means

Psychologically, "not the right person" is the most honest brush-off a prospect can give. They are not saying "I don't need this." They are saying "this isn't mine to decide." Those are very different positions.

Compare it with "not interested," which closes a door. "Not the right person" points at another door. The prospect has no reason to protect it. Giving you a name costs them ten seconds and makes them look helpful. Refusing costs them the awkwardness of being unhelpful.

There is one more catch. Sometimes it is a polite lie, the cheapest exit from the call. You cannot tell which kind you have until you ask a follow-up. That is the reason to ask.

The three-question routine

Run this the moment you hear it. Keep your voice flat and curious, not hopeful.

Question one: "Who would own that?"

Not "can you give me a name?" That sounds like a request for a favour. "Who would own that?" sounds like a simple factual question, and people answer factual questions on reflex.

If it was a lie, this is where it surfaces. They will stall, say "I'd have to check," or sigh. Fine. Thank them and move on. You lost nothing you were going to keep.

Question two: "Would it be okay to say you pointed me their way?"

This is the one most reps skip, and it is the one that does the work. A cold call to a stranger carries zero context. A call that starts "Dana in operations suggested I reach out" carries a reason to listen. (Use the real name, obviously. Dana is a placeholder.)

Asking permission also does something subtle. It makes the referrer a small participant in the outcome. People like to stay consistent with what they just agreed to.

Question three: "Is there a better time or a direct line to catch them?"

You are asking for the cheapest piece of infrastructure: a direct line or a time window. If they give you a time, you now have a scheduled callback with a referral attached. That is a stronger position than most of the "call me back" conversations you currently log.

Whole routine, spoken aloud, takes about twenty seconds.

Why this matters more for senior seats

Senior contacts are where this comes up most naturally. A CEO's conversation is shorter than most people expect: 79 seconds on average. Finance averages 83 seconds. In that window they are deciding whether you are worth their attention, and sometimes the honest answer is "this belongs to someone below me."

Delegation is a normal thing at the top. If a CFO says "talk to my controller," you have not been rejected. You have been routed. The mistake is treating routing like refusal.

And there is a quiet advantage. When you call the person they named, you are not a stranger starting from zero. You are someone a senior colleague sent. That changes how the first ten seconds land.

Log it differently

Here is the operational part, and it is the reason most teams never improve at this. If "not the right person" goes into your CRM as a generic "not interested," nobody learns anything.

Give it its own disposition. Then track three things:

  1. How often your reps ask for the name at all.
  2. How often they get one.
  3. How often the follow-up call with the referral turns into a conversation.

If you do not separate them, you will never know whether the routine works for your list. You will also never see the rep who quietly gets a name every time, and that rep is worth studying.

Do this today

Take the next dial session and write one line on a sticky note: "Who would own that?" Put it on the monitor.

The first time you hear "I'm not the right person," do not say thanks. Ask the three questions, in order, and write down what happened. You will probably have only a few of these conversations this week. That is fine. A few warm intros from the rarest objection beats another pile of cold dials that get nothing.

Treat every "wrong person" as a handoff you are allowed to ask for.

Sales as psychology, weekly

One idea a week on cold calling, objections and getting meetings held. No fluff.